Voyagoux : Tips & Inspiration

ABS or polycarbonate suitcase: which one should you choose?

From the Editorial Team

Two different hard-shell suitcases—one in matte gray and the other in glossy navy blue—stand side by side on the polished floor of a modern departure hall.

A polycarbonate suitcase with a similar construction absorbs impacts better than an ABS suitcase. ABS is a suitable budget choice for those who travel less frequently. How often you travel and whether your suitcase goes in the cabin or the cargo hold determine how much extra durability you need. We’ll help you at Voyagoux choose based on how you’ll use it, not just on the material label. The composition of the shell and the overall quality of the suitcase both matter. Not sure if a hard-shell suitcase is right for your travel style? Hard-shell or soft-shell suitcase?

Here's how the materials vary throughout your trip

Property ABS Polycarbonate
Material Name Acrylonitrile-butadiene-styrene: a plastic used, among other things, for hard suitcase shells. Polycarbonate, abbreviated as PC: a plastic with high impact resistance.
Flexibility Relatively stiff; yields less when pressure is applied to the shell. More flexible; can deform under stress and then spring back.
Impact Resistance More prone to cracking when subjected to a hard, localized impact. More resistant to sudden impacts due to its greater resilience.
Temperature fluctuations Becomes more brittle at low temperatures and is therefore more prone to breaking. Retains its impact resistance over a wider temperature range.
Weight Suitable for lightweight suitcase shells. Also suitable for lightweight suitcase shells.
Purchase price Typically, a lower price level. Typically, prices are higher.

The actual empty weight isn’t determined by the material alone. Dimensions, shell thickness, wheels, the pull handle, and fasteners all play a role. That’s why you should compare suitcases of the same size based on their total weight. A lightweight shell with heavy components doesn’t automatically make for a lightweight suitcase. Want to learn more about how to choose a lightweight suitcase wisely? Continue reading to learn how to choose the best lightweight suitcase.

A scratch is superficial wear; a crack or a loose fastener is structural damage. A shiny, smooth surface shows fine scratches more clearly than a textured finish. That visible difference says little about impact resistance.

A protective case helps protect against dirt and superficial scratches. The shell and construction must be able to withstand the stress caused by drops, impacts, and pressure.

Check what "ABS+PC" means on the material label

ABS+PC is a combination designation, not a fixed quality grade. It can refer to a blend of both plastics or to an ABS shell with an outer layer of polycarbonate. This is different from a shell in which polycarbonate forms the base material throughout the entire thickness of the material.

The label alone does not specify the mixing ratio, layer thickness, or performance. Specific information about the material composition is required for that. A thin PC outer layer does not automatically give an ABS shell the same properties as a shell made entirely of polycarbonate.

There are also differences in quality even within a single material category. The quality of the raw material, the variation in shell thickness, and the production process all influence how well the shell withstands stress. The rating on the label is therefore just the starting point for comparison, not the final verdict.

Choose based on how you travel

  • For an occasional vacation on a limited budget, a well-made ABS suitcase is a logical choice. This is especially true for a road trip where you load the suitcase yourself and don’t move it around much. You have more control over how it’s handled than you do with checked luggage. Focus your budget on finding the right size and a sturdy design, rather than on extra space you don’t need.
  • When you fly frequently and have multiple layovers, your suitcase has to withstand more loading, unloading, and handling. That’s when the extra durability of polycarbonate really pays off. Especially if you check your luggage regularly, the suitcase’s ability to withstand sudden stress becomes a key factor in your decision. After all, a trip with multiple flights isn’t just about the outbound and return legs—it’s also about every layover.
  • When it comes to carry-on luggage, the permitted external dimensions, empty weight, and usable interior space are key factors. Wheels and handles take up space within the external dimensions, while thick padding reduces interior space. Our 55 × 35 × 25 cm carry-on bag represents a size category, not a universal airline standard. Permitted dimensions and weight vary by airline and fare class. Within the rules of your flight, choose a layout that neatly accommodates your daily essentials.
  • With checked luggage, the case is subjected to stacking, pressure, and impacts during handling. Don’t pack it so full that you have to press down on the lid to close the suitcase—that puts strain on the fasteners and seams even before departure. Leave enough space so you can close both halves without using force. A lower empty weight leaves more of your weight allowance for your belongings; that’s why our lightweight suitcases are also worth considering when comparing options.

Also check the parts around the bowl

  • A good closure fits evenly all around. Zippers should glide smoothly around the corners; with frame closures, both halves of the shell should fit together neatly. The lock should also latch and unlock smoothly, without requiring you to force the shell open. A TSA lock allows authorized security personnel to open the suitcase with a special key for inspection. That feature alone says nothing about the build quality of the rest of the suitcase.
  • Wheels, the pull handle, and carrying handles should also function comfortably even when loaded with luggage. Smooth-rolling wheels, a stable, extendable pull handle, and securely attached handles make moving the suitcase easier. Looseness around fasteners and deformation at the corners deserve special attention: forces converge at those points. Our models with 360-degree swivel wheels can be rolled in different directions, even alongside you when you’re walking through a narrow passageway.
  • A well-organized interior layout helps keep your belongings from shifting. Dividers keep both halves organized, and compression straps hold clothes in place when you stand the suitcase upright. A hard shell alone does not provide sufficient protection for fragile items against movement inside. Wrap them separately and avoid leaving empty space around them. Our packing cubes help you organize your clothes and accessories; they are not a substitute for protective packaging for fragile items.
  • Protection against water and dust depends on the overall construction. Seams, zippers, and the connection between the two shell halves also play a role. A plastic exterior absorbs very little moisture on its own, but that doesn’t make the entire suitcase waterproof. Therefore, keep items that need to stay dry in a separate water-resistant bag, especially if your luggage will be left outside for an extended period of time.

Take the warranty and expected lifespan into account

The warranty and repair options are among the factors that determine the value of your suitcase. A warranty covering manufacturing and material defects is different from coverage for normal wear and tear or damage caused by baggage handling. The type of damage and its cause are therefore important factors in assessing warranty claims.

Voyagoux offers a two- or five-year warranty, depending on the model. This warranty is in addition to your statutory rights. With our lifetime service, we’ll continue to assist you with parts, repairs, and advice even after the warranty period ends. A repairable wheel mount or replaceable part can prevent a suitcase that’s still usable from being written off.

Weigh the purchase price against your expected use. If you travel a lot, higher quality becomes more important, but a higher price doesn’t automatically mean a suitcase offers you more value. If you’d like some background on sustainability and quality, read more about traveling with a high-quality suitcase.

When might a different suitcase material be worth considering?

Aluminum is a good choice if you're looking for a rigid shell and sturdy protection. However, this usually comes at the cost of added weight, a higher purchase price, and the risk of visible dents. Furthermore, an aluminum shell is not the same as an aluminum frame: the latter reinforces the sealing edge, while the shell itself can be made of plastic.

Polypropylene is a distinct category of plastic. The material can flex to a relatively large extent and offers a unique balance of flexibility, weight, and impact resistance. It is therefore not just another name for ABS or polycarbonate.

Fabric luggage tends to give more when packed, while a hard shell retains its shape better. If you’re looking for that rigid exterior, you can further compare our hard-shell suitcases based on size, interior layout, and ease of travel.

Practical Questions to Consider When Choosing a Suitcase

Is the suitcase from Action any good?

That depends on the specific model and what you’ll be using it for. A general assessment of quality requires up-to-date model specifications and reliable test data. The store name, a low price, or a list of materials alone is not enough for that. For an occasional car trip, different features are more important than for regular air travel. Relevant criteria include the empty weight, the fasteners, how the wheels and handles are attached, and the finish of the shell. This way, you can assess suitability for your trip, rather than just the price.

Why is it sometimes not recommended to use a luggage strap on your suitcase?

A luggage strap is not generally prohibited or always unsuitable. The main risk lies in loose or protruding parts that could get caught on something during baggage handling. A tightly secured strap with no loose ends is a different matter. Use the strap according to your carrier’s instructions and secure the remaining end. A strap will not repair a damaged clasp or reinforce a weak shell. So don’t view it as a solution for a suitcase that no longer closes properly.

How big does your suitcase need to be for 23 kg?

23 kg is a weight limit, not a fixed suitcase size or capacity in liters. How much space you need depends on the length of your trip, your belongings, and how you pack. The empty weight of the suitcase counts toward that 23 kg limit. For compact luggage, a medium-sized suitcase is a good choice; for more volume, you can compare other checked baggage sizes. Adhere to the maximum external dimensions and weight limits set by your airline and fare class. Weigh the suitcase when it’s fully packed, including any accessories attached to it.